Myth - A Hard drive is quicker than usb flash drive

November 2016




Myth


A hard disk is faster than a USB key.

Reality


TRUE ... but in most cases.

Explanations

  • Hard drives and USB keys are different on the technology used.

Hard drives are mechanical: magnetic trays on which to move the motorized arm.
  • USB keys are electronic: they are mere fleas.


So who is the fastest?

In fact, everything depends on how to use them.

Hard drives have a disadvantage: It takes time to move the playhead to the right place, which takes considerable time. But once the head in the right place, the data rate is phenomenal.

The USB key, it has a very low speed compared to the hard drive. But it did not playhead to move: it therefore immediately accessible at any place of "hard".

Summarize


Hard disk:
  • Slow to get to the right place
  • Very fast transfer


USB key:
  • Very quick to get in the right place
  • Slow transfer

Consequences


Reading large files will typically be faster on hard disk, because the travel time to the file is negligible compared to the time you will read the file.
Reading a large number of small files will often be faster on USB key, since much time is given to fetch the files in the right place. (On a hard disk, the 'crépitements "which means for example when the operating system starts to look or files).

It was after this observation that Microsoft has tried to set up ReadyBoost technology, but without much success.

The problem of access time of hard disk can be mitigated by regular defragmentation.

Note that the disc SSD (Solid State Disk, consisting of memory similar to the USB key), it also gets rid of problems of access time, which offers very attractive performance.
The SSD disk controllers have interlacing algorithms to the records on different chips and use a cache to reduce the problem of flow.

In a way, they meet the best of both worlds.

Related :

This document entitled « Myth - A Hard drive is quicker than usb flash drive » from CCM (ccm.net) is made available under the Creative Commons license. You can copy, modify copies of this page, under the conditions stipulated by the license, as this note appears clearly.