Check register with VLookup

Check Register
Col.A Col. B Col.C Col H Col I
1 Payee Date payee Name Date paid
2 Victor 1-1-17 Victor 1-1-17
3 phone 1-5-17 phone 1-5-17
4 cable 1-10-17 light
5 Cable 1-10-17

Just show the day paid is a different column.

I have looked on line for months, and still cannot locate anything.
Hope you can help.
Here is what I think it is, but does not work.
=IF(B1:B5=VLOOKUP(H1:H5,3))

Thank you for your help.
Victor