When I'm creating a game, we can't even find the game with my 2nd laptop.
Both are laptops connected to the same wifi. Both run windows 8.1.
All 4 serial keys are legit (even tho this does not matter for LAN).
What I've tried till now:
It's definitely not the firewall, i've allowed all the warcraft .exes and also in the advanced firewall settings. Even with both firewalls off it does not work.
I CAN ping from both laptops to eachother.
I disabled the modem firewall.
I run both games in Administrator mode.
I can play through battle.net via internet with eachother (not private session, but public). But I prefer to play on LAN, it really should just work.
I tried finding eachother via Hamachi, didn't work.